Buyers and procurement teams use a small set of tactics again and again: the flinch, the higher authority, the "budget is fixed" line, nibbling, the competitor quote, silence, the good cop–bad cop routine, time pressure, salami slicing and the walk-away bluff. None of them is illegal and most are not even dishonest. They work because the seller has not prepared. Recognise the tactic, name it to yourself, and respond with a plan instead of a concession.

In the PowerFULL Negotiator programme there is a module I call the Tricky 10: the manipulation tactics that cost sellers the most margin. When I run it, the reaction in the room is always the same. People laugh, because they recognise every single one, and then they go quiet, because they realise how much each one has cost them.

Here are ten you will meet across the table, and what to do about each.

1. The Flinch

You state your price and the buyer reacts as if you have insulted them. "What? That much?" The aim is to make you doubt your number and start discounting before they have even made an offer.

Counter: say nothing for a moment, then calmly restate the value behind the price. A flinch is theatre. The worst response is an immediate "but we can look at it."

2. The Higher Authority

"I like it, but my director will never approve this number." The buyer becomes your friend, and an invisible person becomes the villain. You end up negotiating against someone you never meet.

Counter: before you negotiate, ask, "Apart from you, who else is involved in the final decision?" If an authority appears later, offer to present to them directly, or make any change conditional: "If I can do that, can you get approval this week?"

3. "Our Budget Is Fixed"

Budgets are rarely as fixed as they sound. This line is often a test to see whether your price moves.

Counter: do not cut price to fit the budget. Change the scope to fit it. "Here is what we can deliver within that budget, and here is what it leaves out." Now the buyer chooses between value and money, not between you and a discount.

4. The Nibble

The deal is agreed and then: "Oh, and you'll include free delivery, right?" Small requests at the end, when you are relieved and want to close.

Counter: every nibble gets a price or a trade. "Happy to look at delivery. Can we move payment terms to 30 days?" Nibbling stops the moment it stops being free.

"Never give anything away without getting something back. A concession without a trade does not build goodwill. It teaches the buyer to ask again."

5. The Competitor Quote

"Your competitor is 15% cheaper." Sometimes true, sometimes invented, almost always incomplete.

Counter: ask to compare like for like: scope, quality, delivery, support, risk. Then make the difference in value visible. If the competitor truly offers the same thing for less, the question is not price. It is why the buyer is still talking to you.

6. Silence

The buyer simply stops talking after your offer. Most sellers cannot bear it and fill the silence with a better offer.

Counter: silence works both ways. Ask a question and wait. The person who speaks first after an offer usually gives something away.

7. Good Cop, Bad Cop

One person is aggressive and unreasonable. The other is friendly and "trying to help you" get past their difficult colleague. The friendly one is not on your side.

Counter: recognise the routine and treat both people as one team. Make every concession to the team, conditional and traded, never as a favour to the "nice" one.

8. Time Pressure

"We need your best price by 5 pm today or we go with the other supplier." Deadlines push people to decide fast and badly.

Counter: ask what happens after the deadline, and check whether it is real. Your own deadlines matter too. A seller with a quarter-end target is far easier to squeeze, which is why preparation includes knowing your own pressure points.

9. Salami Slicing

Instead of asking for 10% off, the buyer asks for 2% here, an extra service there, a longer warranty, faster delivery. Each slice looks small. Together they are your margin.

Counter: ask for the full list of requests before you respond to any of them. "Is there anything else, apart from these?" Then negotiate the package as a whole.

10. The Walk-Away Bluff

The buyer stands up, closes the folder, or goes cold for a week. The message: give more, or lose the deal.

Counter: this is where your BATNA, your best alternative if there is no deal, does its work. If you have defined your MDO, LDO and BATNA before the meeting, a walk-away is information, not a crisis. If you have not, it becomes panic. I explain how to set all three in MDO, LDO and BATNA: the three numbers every negotiator must know.

The Pattern Behind All Ten

Why These Tactics Work, and How to Stop Them Working

  • They exploit unpreparedness. A seller without a plan reacts. A seller with a plan recognises the tactic and follows the plan.
  • They rely on free concessions. Make every concession conditional and traded, and most tactics lose their reward.
  • They target emotion. Relief, fear and the wish to be liked. Naming the tactic to yourself takes the emotion out.

A Note for Procurement Teams

If you buy for a living, this list is not a playbook to use blindly. Tactics win a negotiation once and damage a supplier relationship for years. The strongest procurement teams I train negotiate on total value: price, terms, quality, risk and the relationship. More on that in negotiation training for procurement teams.

Frequently Asked Questions

What are the most common negotiation tactics buyers use?

The most common buyer tactics are the flinch, the higher authority, the fixed budget, the nibble, the competitor quote, silence, good cop–bad cop, time pressure, salami slicing and the walk-away bluff. They work mainly when the seller has not prepared a plan, a walk-away point and a list of things to trade.

How do you counter a buyer who asks for a discount?

Never give a discount for nothing. Ask what the buyer can give in return, such as a longer contract, larger volume, faster payment or a case study, and trade a lower price only for something of value. If the budget is the issue, change the scope instead of the price.

Is it ethical to use negotiation tactics?

Recognising tactics is essential for both sellers and buyers. Using them aggressively may win one deal but damages trust in long-term business relationships. The most effective negotiators prepare thoroughly, trade rather than concede, and look for value both sides can accept.

Train your team to see these tactics coming.

PowerFULL Negotiator is a 2–3 day negotiation skills programme where your team practises against these tactics in live role-plays built around your own deals. Prefer to start with the book? PowerFULL Negotiator is on Amazon.

Contact Mihir → View the PowerFULL Negotiator Programme →
Mihir Koltharkar
Mihir Koltharkar
Top 20 Global B2B Sales & Negotiation Trainer · TEDx Speaker · Author

Mihir has trained corporate teams across 14 countries over 26 years — delivering 2,500+ sessions for companies including Abbott, JP Morgan Chase, Boston Consulting Group, Safaricom, Audi, Almarai, Shapoorji Pallonji, Ferrero, and 50+ others. He is the creator of the Impossible Sales and PowerFULL Negotiator programmes, and is ranked among the Top 20 Global Sales Trainers worldwide alongside Brian Tracy, Jordan Belfort, and Victor Antonio.